The 1-6 home defeat to Manchester City on 23rd October 2011 was billed the biggest Manchester derby in decades, and it turned out to be Manchester United’s worst ever home defeat in the Premier League era, and the worst defeat in the 25 years of Sir Alex Ferguson’s reign as manager.
A scoreline you’d never expect to see at Old Trafford

Coincidentally, Man Utd’s Jonathan Evans, who was sent off in the 47th minute, was wearing the number 6 shirt.
It was the reigning league champion’s first home defeat in 18 months (since April 2010) i.e. 25 matches and on 19 home wins on the trot – so City’s margin of victory is especially memorable.
It was City’s biggest away league win since the 6-0 victory at Burnley in March 1999.
Ferguson himself described the defeat as his worst in his more than 50 years of involvement in the game:
It was our worst ever day. It’s the worst result in my history, ever. Even as a player I don’t think I ever lost 6-1. That’s challenge for me too. I can’t believe the scoreline. The first goal was a blow for sure but it was retrievable at 1-0. The sending off was a killer for us. We kept attacking when we went 4-1 down and we should have just said: ‘We’ve had our day.’” We just kept attacking. They were attacking three versus two. It was crazy football. I thought with the experience we’ve got – Rio Ferdinand, Patrice Evra – they would [defend more] but we just kept attacking. Sometimes there has to be common sense about it. It was a bad day. What did concern me was the goals for and against. Goal difference may count. Last year it was in our favour. Most years it is in our favour. This time maybe not. We’ll come back. By January we’ll be okay. We usually get the show on the road in the second half of the season and that will have to be the case. We’ve played all the teams around us and they have all to play each other so the second half of the season is important to us now. We will react, no question about that. It’s a perfect result for us to react to because there is a lot of embarrassment in the dressing room and that will make an impact.
Some other bad defeats during his reign as United manager:
0-5 at Newcastle and 3-6 at Southampton in 1996, yet Man Utd went on to win the league title.
0-5 at Chelsea in 1999, ending United’s 29-match unbeaten run. Yet, Man Utd went on to win the league title.
1-4 at home to Liverpool in 2009, yet Man Utd went on to win the league title.
1-4 at home to QPR in 1992. That season, Leeds won the league title.
1-5 away to Man City in 1989. That season Liverpool won the league title.
So one could say that the hairdryer treatment will be at full throttle after the match.
The Reds’ worst ever home defeat was 1-7 to Newcastle United in the old First Division, which happened way back in 1927. They also had lost 0-6 twice at home: to Aston Villa in 1914 and to Huddersfield Town in 1930.
Man Utd’s worst ever defeat is 0-7, which happened 3 times:
- at Blackburn Rovers in 1926
- at Aston Villa in 1930
- at Wolverhampton Wanderers in 1931
Social networks were abuzz after the match against their rivals, including:
obefield (via his blog sokernet)
M6nch6st6r Unit6d
Manchester City’s new logo:

bongkersz (via twitter):
1Enam. 1Six. Latest additions to the ’1′ craze. 1Toilet. 1Notebook. 1Kedai. 1Telur.
Six and the City!
Khairy Jamaluddin (via twitter):
Bola itu bulat. That’s all I’ve got tonight. 1-6.
TheLoneTweet (via twitter):
Man United were holding out – in prep for the big midweek tie with Aldershot
asoundreaction (via twitter):
Holy sh*t. Just seen the football score. Forget the hairdryer treatment let the tea cup throwing commence
anthraxxxx (via twitter):
tak kisah siapa kalah, janji Manchester yang menang #tuitsedaphati
MukhrizMahathir (via twitter):
Regime change in Manchester! 6-1!!! Its a masacre!
mpkotabelud (via twitter):
Pedih! RT @NoorAzam: Sebelum ucap selamat malam, kita ucap … SAAAATUUUU? Malaysia. SAAAATUUU? Malaysia. SAAATUUU? ENAAAAAM. Selamat malam.
ThankUAndGnite (via twitter):
On a scale of 1-6, how humiliated do you think Man Utd fans are now? #Manchesterderby
JosuaClement_S (via twitter):
Losing 6-1 at home with your strongest team is way worse than losing 8-2 away with your reserves playing.
Popularity: 1% [?]